• My Listings
Expert Circle
  • Expert Panels
    Expert panel: What are the benefits of coaching and mentoring?

    Expert panel: What are the benefits of coaching and mentoring?

    Expert Panel: What is one change you recommend making to enhance culture and productivity

    Expert Panel: What is one change you recommend making to enhance culture and productivity

    Expert Panel: Hybrid working – What is the best model to move forward, how should time be split between home and office?

    Expert Panel: Hybrid working – What is the best model to move forward, how should time be split between home and office?

    Expert Panel: How to develop a content strategy

    Expert Panel: How to develop a content strategy

  • Get Featured
    Contribute to the panel: If you could only do one thing in an organisation to improve the sense of belonging, what would it be?

    Contribute to the panel: If you could only do one thing in an organisation to improve the sense of belonging, what would it be?

    Contribute to the panel: How do you deal with the negativity without letting it drag you down as the leader?

    Contribute to the panel: How do you deal with the negativity without letting it drag you down as the leader?

    Contribute to the panel: What are the benefits of coaching and mentoring?

    Contribute to the panel: What are the benefits of coaching and mentoring?

    Expert Panel

    Contribute to the Expert Panel: What are the important factors to consider before starting a business?

    Contribute to the panel: How do you market to two different audiences?

    Contribute to the panel: How do you market to two different audiences?

    Contribute to the Expert Panel: What is one change you recommend making to enhance culture and productivity?

    Contribute to the Expert Panel: What is one change you recommend making to enhance culture and productivity?

  • Join Expert Circle
  • Media Pack
    • Branded Content
No Result
View All Result
Expert Circle
No Result
View All Result
Home Book Club

Good Strategy, Bad Strategy – book review

by James Chaplin
October 23, 2022
in Book Club, Book Review
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
Good Strategy, Bad Strategy – book review
4.5k
SHARES
15.4k
VIEWS
Share on LinkedinShare on Twitter

In this book, Rumelt argues that most businesses either don’t have a strategy, or what they do have is not fit for purpose. With that, he starts by deconstructing all the ways businesses fail when they assemble their strategy, before going on to outline in detail the key elements a business leader should be thinking about when implementing their own. In fact, so groundbreaking was this book, that when it was first published in 2011, it was considered by the Financial Times, to be the business book of the year.
Starting with deconstructing ‘Bad Strategy’ he talks about the typical mistakes made, where specifically he references four hallmarks:

  • Fluff – A form of gibberish masquerading as a strategy. It uses Sunday words ‘words that are inflated and unnecessarily abstruse) and apparently esoteric concepts to create the illusion of high-level thinking.
  • Failure to face the challenge – Bad strategy fails to recognise or define the challenge. When you cannot define the challenge, you cannot evaluate a strategy or improve it.
  • Mistaking goals for strategy – Many bad strategies are statements of desire rather than plans for overcoming obstacles.
  • Bad strategic objectives – A strategic objective is set by a leader as a means to an end. Strategic objectives are bad when they fail to address critical issues or when they are impracticable.

He then goes on to describe good strategy as “a coherent action backed up by an argument, an effective mixture of thought and action with a basic underlying structure, called the kernel. A good strategy may consist of more than the kernel, but without it, there is a serious problem. The kernel of the strategy consists of three elements:

  • A diagnosis that defines or explains the nature of the challenge. A good diagnosis simplifies the often overwhelming complexity of reality by identifying certain aspects as critical
  • A guiding policy for dealing with the challenge. This is an overall approach chosen to cope with or overcome the obstacles identified in the diagnosis.”
  • A set of coherent actions that are designed to carry out the guiding policy. these are the steps that are coordinated with one another to work together in accomplishing the guiding policy.”

Later he talks about competitive advantage, which he describes as the ability to either produce at a lower cost than competitors or generate more perceived value, were achieving this state is central to building an unassailable market position.
Then in the final segment of the book he talks about what it means to think like a strategist, where he starts by discussing the science of strategy, so entering a hypothesis which you test against, and gives numerous case studies on how this can be done properly. With that, he goes on to discuss the importance of deep thought, meaning understanding in detail all the specifics, when designing a strategy.

In summary, this is a heavyweight book and while not the easiest to read, it is highly rewarding for those who perservere. The subject matter is relevant to anyone who is responsible for managing a business, solution or product as good strategy is at the heart of success, yet so often the correct elements aren’t brought together correctly at the planning stage. This book is an attempt to help such leaders take control so they execute more effectively. Highly recommended.

Share314Tweet1120Share1792SendShareSend

James Chaplin

Related Posts

No B.S. Trust Based Marketing: The Ultimate Guide to Creating Trust in an Understandibly Un-trusting World
Book Club

No B.S. Trust Based Marketing: The Ultimate Guide to Creating Trust in an Understandibly Un-trusting World

January 28, 2023
5
No B.S. Time Management for Entrepreneurs: The Ultimate No-Holds-Barred Kick-Butt Take-No-Prisoners Guide to Time Productivity and Sanity (No B.S. Series)
Book Club

No B.S. Time Management for Entrepreneurs: The Ultimate No-Holds-Barred Kick-Butt Take-No-Prisoners Guide to Time Productivity and Sanity (No B.S. Series)

January 27, 2023
5
No B.S. Price Strategy: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Kick Butt Take No Prisoner Guide to Profits, Power, and Prosperity
Book Club

No B.S. Price Strategy: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Kick Butt Take No Prisoner Guide to Profits, Power, and Prosperity

January 25, 2023
5
No B.S. Marketing to the Affluent: No Holds Barred, Take No Prisoners, Guide to Getting Really Rich 3rd
Book Club

No B.S. Marketing to the Affluent: No Holds Barred, Take No Prisoners, Guide to Getting Really Rich 3rd

January 25, 2023
5
No B.S. Guide to Marketing to Leading Edge Boomers & Seniors: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoners Roadmap to the Money
Book Club

No B.S. Guide to Marketing to Leading Edge Boomers & Seniors: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoners Roadmap to the Money

January 24, 2023
5
No B.S. Grassroots Marketing: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoner Guide to Growing Sales and Profits of Local Small Businesses
Book Club

No B.S. Grassroots Marketing: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoner Guide to Growing Sales and Profits of Local Small Businesses

January 23, 2023
5
No B.S. Guide to Maximum Referrals and Customer Retention: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Plan to Securing New Customers and Maximum Profits
Book Club

No B.S. Guide to Maximum Referrals and Customer Retention: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Plan to Securing New Customers and Maximum Profits

January 22, 2023
5
No B.S. Grassroots Marketing: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoner Guide to Growing Sales and Profits of Local Small Businesses
Book Club

No B.S. Grassroots Marketing: The Ultimate No Holds Barred Take No Prisoner Guide to Growing Sales and Profits of Local Small Businesses

January 21, 2023
6
No B.S. Guide to Direct Response Social Media Marketing (2nd Edition): No B.S. Series
Book Club

No B.S. Guide to Direct Response Social Media Marketing (2nd Edition): No B.S. Series

January 20, 2023
5
No B.S. Business Success in the New Economy
Book Club

No B.S. Business Success in the New Economy

January 19, 2023
5
Next Post
The Making of a Manager – Book Review

The Making of a Manager - Book Review

Best Quotes On Leadership

Best Quotes On Leadership

If you share dog pictures, you’re not a professional!

If you share dog pictures, you're not a professional!

Call to Action

Categories

  • Book Club
    • Book Review
    • Business Library
  • Business Management
    • Accounting
    • Careers and Education
    • HR & Recruitment
    • Startup
  • Current Affairs
    • Notes From Ukraine
  • Expert Panel
  • Finance
    • Investing
  • Get Featured
  • Leadership
    • Motivational
  • Lifestyle
  • Marketing
    • Blogging
    • Design
    • Digital Marketing
    • Email Marketing
    • Networking
    • Podcast
  • Sales
    • Objection Handling

Advertisement

Black Friday Week 2021 v2

Categories

  • Book Club (107)
    • Book Review (18)
    • Business Library (83)
  • Business Management (28)
    • Accounting (1)
    • Careers and Education (2)
    • HR & Recruitment (6)
    • Startup (6)
  • Current Affairs (17)
    • Notes From Ukraine (17)
  • Expert Panel (11)
  • Finance (1)
    • Investing (1)
  • Get Featured (10)
  • Leadership (34)
    • Motivational (12)
  • Lifestyle (9)
  • Marketing (60)
    • Blogging (17)
    • Design (1)
    • Digital Marketing (22)
    • Email Marketing (1)
    • Networking (4)
    • Podcast (2)
  • Sales (4)
    • Objection Handling (1)

An Award-winning Platform

Top categories on Expert Circle

  • Book Club
  • Business Management
  • Leadership
  • Marketing & Sales

Opportunities on Expert Circle

  • Branded Content
  • Promote Your Website
  • Media Pack
  • Get Featured
  • Expert Panels
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 Expert Circle

No Result
View All Result
  • All posts by Experts
  • Get Featured
  • Expert Panels
  • Promote Your Website
  • Branded Content
  • Media Pack

© 2021 Expert Circle

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.